The legal battle over the U.S. Green Card Lottery continues as a new DV-2027 lawsuit challenges the administration’s failure to open registration for the Diversity Visa program. This latest legal action comes just days after an appeals court halted a previous order that would have required the government to restart the program.
Ivan Ivannikov vs. Secretary of State Marco Rubio
On November 1, Ivan Ivannikov, a Russian national residing in Los Angeles, filed a new DV-2027 lawsuit against Secretary of State Marco Rubio in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California. This DV-2027 lawsuit seeks to legally compel the U.S. Department of State to open the registration periods for both the DV-2027 and DV-2028 programs.
Unlike the previous plaintiff, Ivannikov is an individual who directly qualifies to enter the program and has expressed his intent to participate in both the DV-2027 and DV-2028 lotteries if the registration windows open. Born in Moscow, Ivannikov studied law at the Higher School of Economics before moving to the U.S. as an international student. He earned an LL.M. from the University of California, Irvine School of Law, passed the California Bar Exam, and now runs his own immigration law practice assisting clients with employment-based visas and green cards.
Why the Previous DV-2027 Lawsuit Was Halted
This active DV-2027 lawsuit represents a renewed strategy following a setback in a previous case filed by an immigration law firm, Red Eagle Law. The timeline of the prior legal challenge includes:
- October 14: A federal district court granted Red Eagle Law a preliminary injunction, ordering the State Department to announce the DV-2027 registration period by October 29 and begin accepting applications by November 1.
- October 29: The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals granted the government’s request for an emergency stay, freezing the lower court’s mandate while the appeal proceeds.
- Appellate Reasoning: The Ninth Circuit ruled that the law firm was unlikely to establish that its business interests fell within the group protected by the Diversity Visa statute, with Judge N. Randy Smith separately concluding the firm lacked constitutional standing.

The Value of the Green Card Lottery
By introducing a plaintiff with direct standing to participate in the lottery, legal representatives behind this DV-2027 lawsuit hope to bypass the judicial hurdles that stalled the previous case.
“The Diversity Visa lottery has added immeasurable value to the United States. When noncitizens enter the lottery, it is because they believe in the promise of the American dream,” stated Curtis Lee Morrison, an attorney representing Ivannikov. “Allowing self-selected strivers from across the globe to be part of the American dream, makes the American dream stronger, and more beautiful. Being a child of immigrants, you’d think Secretary Rubio would get that.”
Background: What is the Diversity Visa Program?
The Diversity Immigrant Visa Program, commonly known as the Green Card lottery, is a congressional mandate designed to diversify the immigrant population of the United States. Under standard operations, the U.S. government makes up to 55,000 permanent resident visas available each year to individuals from countries with historically low rates of immigration to the U.S.
Typically, the registration period opens in October, allowing millions of hopeful applicants worldwide to submit their information for free. A randomized computer drawing then selects applicants who can proceed with the rigorous background checks and interviews required to obtain a visa. For many individuals without close family ties or employer sponsorship in the U.S., the Diversity Visa lottery represents their only viable pathway to achieving the American dream.
The ongoing legal dispute underscores the immense popularity and critical nature of this program for aspiring immigrants worldwide. The outcome of this DV-2027 lawsuit could set a significant precedent for how the government manages congressional immigration mandates in the future, particularly when administrative delays effectively suspend established pathways to permanent residency. Applicants remain in a holding pattern, closely watching the courts to determine if and when they can submit their entries.
